| 2011 | The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe | Robert Oden |
| Chicago | Keith Sweat |
| 1940s Radio Hour | Amanda Lindsey |
| 2012 | The Crucible | Elise Dotson |
| Hairspray | Whitney Van Matre |
| The Neverending Story | Sophie Decker |
| Frankenstein | Heather Shepherd |
| Fruitcakes | Nicole Curry |
| 2013 | The Outsiders | Jason Lindsey |
| Once Upon a Mattress | James Brooks |
| Alice in Wonderland | Jak Johnson |
| Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Whitney Thompson |
| Yes, Virginia there is a Santa Claus | Kathy Dolen |
| 2014 | A Tale of Cinderella | Jill Shedd |
| Legally Blonde | Keisha Rawls |
| A Year with Frog and Toad | Hunter Mason |
| Spamalot | Kelly Jackson |
| A Nice Family Gathering | Diane Morris |
| 2015 | A Few Good Men | Floyd Walker |
| Next to Normal | Christopher Gansel |
| A Little Princess | Deena Holt |
| Mary Poppins | Jeff Cooper |
| Christmas Belles | Renee Yawn |
| 2016 | Of Mice and Men | Matt Middlebrook |
| 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | Alex Eberhart |
| Jack and the Giant Beanstalk | Shelby Freshwater |
| Gypsy | Shelia Gatlin |
| A Nice Family Christmas | Matthew Rodgers |
| 2017 | Dearly Beloved | Meggie Foster McCann |
| Big Fish | Laramy Wells |
| Still Life with Iris | Wade McGlamery |
| All Shook Up | Sara Norsworthy |
| Miracle on 34th Street | Steve Green |
| 2018 | Moon Over Buffalo | Eric Barker |
| Bridge To Terabithia | Anna Grace Jones |
| 9 to 5 | Bethany Wells |
| Death Trap | Calvin Wickham |
| Southern Hospitality | Melissa Martin |
| 2019 | These Shining Lives | Brad Crawford |
| Great American Trailer Park Musical | Cassie Crisp |
| The Odd Couple | Shannon Murphy |
| Memphis | Amanda Wharton |
| A Seussified Christmas Carol | Amy Williams |
| 2020 | Steel Magnolias | Mallory Arrington |
| Mamma Mia | Kendra Cowart |
| Elf: The Musical | Luke Buffalow |
| 2021 | Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time | Jalen Tucker |
| In the Heights | Autumn Stephens |
| The Color Purple | Sharon Simms |
| The Red Velvet Cake War | Olivia Vicos |
| Every Christmas Story Ever Told (And Then Some) | Kendra Cowart |
| 2022 | Newsies | Kavon Sadler |
| Morningside | Stacy Morris |
| Rent | Azhane Kennedy |
| The Last Five Years | Zoe Reddick |
| Cabaret | Jack Mackim |
| Let Nothing You Dismay | Tori René |
| 2023 | The Play That Goes Wrong | Gavin Llambes |
| Once on This Island | Zolly Brown |
| Dreamgirls | Brandi Neal |